Quick answer: Medical negligence
Medical negligence is a failure by a doctor or hospital to meet the standard of care expected of a reasonably skilled professional, causing injury or death. The usual remedy is a compensation complaint before the Consumer Commission, which must be filed within two years. A criminal case under Section 106(1) of the BNS is possible only for gross negligence and ordinarily needs a credible expert medical opinion first.
Last reviewed: 1 November 2026. Written by the office of Adv. Mridul Jindal, Law Chambers of Mridul Jindal, Indirapuram, Ghaziabad.
Legal Help After Wrong Treatment, Surgical Error or Hospital Negligence
This page is for patients and families in Ghaziabad (including Indirapuram, Vaishali and Vasundhara), Noida and Delhi who believe that treatment went wrong because of a doctor's or hospital's carelessness. Not every bad outcome is negligence. The law asks whether the doctor failed to do what a reasonably competent practitioner in the same field would have done, and whether that failure caused the harm.
The Supreme Court held in Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha (1995) that medical services fall within consumer protection law, which is why most compensation claims are filed before the Consumer Commission. Services given free of charge to every patient generally fall outside it.
How Is Medical Negligence Proved?
Duty of care: A doctor-patient relationship existed, so the doctor or hospital owed you a duty.
Breach: The treatment fell below the accepted standard. Courts apply the Bolam test: a doctor is not negligent if the treatment accords with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion.
Causation and damage: The breach, and not the underlying illness, caused the injury, disability or death.
Expert evidence: Most cases turn on an independent opinion from a doctor in the same specialty. In criminal matters, Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005) requires gross negligence or recklessness and a credible expert opinion before a doctor is prosecuted.
Your Legal Options
| Remedy | What it gives you | Time limit and key point |
|---|---|---|
| Consumer complaint | Compensation, refund of fees, costs | Two years from the cause of action (Consumer Protection Act, 2019, s.69); a delay can be condoned for sufficient cause |
| Criminal complaint | Prosecution of the doctor: up to two years' imprisonment and fine for a registered medical practitioner causing death during a medical procedure (BNS, s.106(1)) | Only for gross negligence; expert opinion is usually required first |
| Complaint to the State Medical Council | Disciplinary action such as a warning or suspension of registration; it does not award compensation | Filed with the Delhi or Uttar Pradesh Medical Council, depending on where the doctor is registered |
| Civil suit for damages | Compensation through a civil court | Used where the claim does not suit the consumer route |
Which Consumer Commission Should You File In?
The forum depends on the consideration paid for the treatment, and not on the compensation you claim.
| Consideration paid | Commission |
|---|---|
| Up to ₹50 lakh | District Consumer Commission (for example Ghaziabad or Gautam Buddh Nagar) |
| Above ₹50 lakh and up to ₹2 crore | State Consumer Commission (Lucknow for Uttar Pradesh; Delhi State Commission for Delhi) |
| Above ₹2 crore | National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi |
A patient who paid ₹2 lakh for a surgery but claims ₹2 crore in compensation still files before the District Commission. You may file where you live or work, or where the hospital is located.
What to Collect Before You Meet a Lawyer
1. Complete medical records: Admission and discharge summary, prescriptions, doctors' and nurses' notes, operation notes, consent forms, test reports, scans and ICU charts. Ask for copies in writing and keep proof of the request.
2. Bills and payment receipts: These prove that you are a consumer and fix the forum.
3. Timeline: Dates of symptoms, treatment, complications and any second opinion.
4. Independent opinion: A report from a doctor in the same specialty, ideally from a government or teaching hospital, on what went wrong.
5. Post-mortem report and police papers if the patient died.
How a Medical Negligence Case Proceeds
1. Record review and expert opinion: We read the records with an independent specialist before deciding whether to proceed.
2. Legal notice: A notice to the doctor and hospital setting out the negligence and the compensation claimed.
3. Complaint: Filing before the correct Consumer Commission (online filing through e-Daakhil is available), with affidavits and records.
4. Evidence and hearing: Medical expert evidence and cross-examination of the doctor.
5. Order and appeal: Compensation can cover medical expenses, loss of income, pain and suffering and costs. Orders can be appealed to the State and then National Commission.
Think the Treatment Was Careless?
If you or a family member suffered harm during treatment in Ghaziabad, Noida or Delhi, bring the medical records and bills and we can tell you whether a claim is worth pursuing, and where. Time limits are strict, so do not wait.
Frequently Asked Questions
It is a breach of the duty of care that a doctor or hospital owes a patient, where the treatment falls below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner and causes injury or death.
A consumer complaint must be filed within two years from the date the cause of action arises, under Section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The two years usually run from when the negligence became apparent. The Commission can condone delay for sufficient cause.
Jurisdiction depends on the consideration paid for the treatment: the District Commission up to ₹50 lakh, the State Commission from ₹50 lakh to ₹2 crore, and the National Commission above ₹2 crore.
Yes, but only in serious cases. Section 106(1) of the BNS provides imprisonment of up to two years and a fine for a registered medical practitioner who causes death by a rash or negligent act in a medical procedure. Under Jacob Mathew, criminal liability needs gross negligence and ordinarily a credible expert opinion first.
No. Medicine carries risk, and a poor result alone does not prove negligence. You must show that the treatment fell below accepted standards and that this caused the harm.
In practice, yes. Most cases are won or lost on an independent opinion from a doctor in the same specialty, and criminal complaints against doctors generally require one.
Yes. A hospital can be liable for its own deficiency and for the acts of the doctors and staff it employs, so both are usually named in the complaint.
The Commission can award medical expenses, loss of income or earning capacity, compensation for pain, suffering and mental agony, and litigation costs. The amount depends on the facts and the evidence.
Services given free of charge to all patients are generally outside the Act, as the Supreme Court held in V.P. Shantha. If the hospital charges some patients and treats others free, the position needs to be examined case by case.
Yes. A complaint to the State Medical Council can lead to disciplinary action against the doctor, but it does not give you compensation. It can be pursued alongside a consumer complaint.
Legal basis
- Consumer Protection Act, 2019, section 69 (limitation) and the Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021
- Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, section 106(1)
- Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005), Supreme Court of India
- Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha (1995), Supreme Court of India
This page is general information, not legal advice for your case. Last reviewed 1 November 2026.
Need advice on this?
Speak to Adv. Mridul Jindal about your options. Consultations are confidential.
💻 Consult in person at Indirapuram, or online by WhatsApp call, Google Meet or phone.
Disclaimer
The Bar Council of India does not permit advocates to advertise or solicit work. By clicking “I Agree”, you acknowledge that:
- you are seeking information about Law Chambers of Mridul Jindal of your own accord, and there has been no advertisement, solicitation or inducement of any kind;
- the content of this website is for general information only and is not legal advice;
- using this website, or contacting us through it, does not by itself create an advocate–client relationship.
